Logo
Searching Tips

When searching Forecite California, there are shortcuts you can take to find the information you are looking for:

1. By Code Section:

Forecite uses standard abbreviations for different types of codes. Those abbreviations can be found below:

Codes:
CCR California Code of Regulations
Corp C Corporations Code
EC Evidence Code
FG Fish and Game Code
GC Government Code
HN Harbors & Navigation Code
HS Health & Safety Code
PC Penal Code
RT Revenue & Tax Code
VC Vehicle Code
WI Welfare & Institutions Code

Using these codes to search is very simple. For example, if you wanted to search for Penal Code section 20, you would type PC 20 into the search box.

2. By CALJIC Number:

Since Forecite is indexed to CALJIC, searching for CALJIC numbers is easy. For example, to search for CALJIC 3.16, you would type 3.16 into the search box.

3. By Case Name or Citation:

To find a case or citation, simply enter all or part of the case’s citation. Since many cases are known only by one name involved, it is often helpful to not search for the entire citation. For example, if you were searching for references to People v. Geiger (84) 35 C3d 510, 526 [199 CR 45], you could search for People v. Geiger or just Geiger. Searching for Geiger might be more helpful since it would find references to the case that do not include the full citation.

  • Contact Us
  • Log In
  • My Account

  • Home
  • Firm Overview
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Practice Areas
  • Verdicts & Settlements
  • News & media
  • Blog
  • Contact

Back to  Previous Page
Back to top

SERIES 500 HOMICIDE

F 510 NOTES

TABLE OF CONTENTS
F 510 Note 1 Instruction On Both Accident And Self-Defense
F 510 Note 2 Self-Defense Available When Defendant Only Threatens To Use Force

Return to Series 500 Table of Contents.


F 510 Note 1 Instruction On Both Accident And Self-Defense

“The bulk of the authority is that a defendant’s assertion of accident may be disregarded by the jury in an appropriate case, and will not foreclose jury instruction on self-defense when there exists substantial evidence that the shooting was intentional (and met the other requirements of self-defense). (People v. Barton (1995) 12 C4th 186, 202–203 [finding sufficient evidence of intentional shooting in imperfect self-defense despite the defendant’s assertion that the shooting was accidental]; People v. Elize (1999) 71 CA4th 605, 610 [“A jury … could disbelieve defendant’s testimony that the firing was accidental, and decide instead that he had fired intentionally, either actually attempting to hit one of the [assailants] or to shock them into breaking off their attack.”]; People v. Mayweather (1968) 259 CA2d 752, 756 [jury could have found a volitional shooting in self-defense despite defendant’s assertion of accident].)” (People v. Villanueva (2008)169 CA4th 41, 51-52.)

The notes following CC 510, the jury instruction for excusable homicide committed by accident, there is a note stating that in People v. Curtis (1994) 30 CA4th 1337 “the court held that the claim that a killing was accidental bars the defendant from relying on traditional self-defense … as a defense … .” (The note goes on to disagree with this purported holding in light of the more recent authority of People v. Elize, supra, 71 CA4th 605.) However, People v. Villanueva, supra,169 CA4th at 52 disagreed with the CALCRIM interpretation of Curtis: “In that case, the court recognized the legal proposition that while a defendant’s assertion of accident is inconsistent with imperfect self-defense, the jury could reject the defendant’s testimony and find an intentional shooting in imperfect self-defense. The court simply found no evidence of an intentional shooting in imperfect self-defense in that case. (People v. Curtis, supra, 30 CA4th at pp. 1355-1356.)”

Thus, when appropriate the judge should instruct on accident and both perfect and imperfect self-defense. (People v. Villanueva, supra,169 CA4th at 52-53.)


F 510 Note 2 Self-Defense Available When Defendant Only Threatens To Use Force

See FORECITE F 505.6 Inst 5.

  • Register as New User
  • Contact Us
© James Publishing, Inc. (866) 72-JAMES