Logo
Searching Tips

When searching Forecite California, there are shortcuts you can take to find the information you are looking for:

1. By Code Section:

Forecite uses standard abbreviations for different types of codes. Those abbreviations can be found below:

Codes:
CCR California Code of Regulations
Corp C Corporations Code
EC Evidence Code
FG Fish and Game Code
GC Government Code
HN Harbors & Navigation Code
HS Health & Safety Code
PC Penal Code
RT Revenue & Tax Code
VC Vehicle Code
WI Welfare & Institutions Code

Using these codes to search is very simple. For example, if you wanted to search for Penal Code section 20, you would type PC 20 into the search box.

2. By CALJIC Number:

Since Forecite is indexed to CALJIC, searching for CALJIC numbers is easy. For example, to search for CALJIC 3.16, you would type 3.16 into the search box.

3. By Case Name or Citation:

To find a case or citation, simply enter all or part of the case’s citation. Since many cases are known only by one name involved, it is often helpful to not search for the entire citation. For example, if you were searching for references to People v. Geiger (84) 35 C3d 510, 526 [199 CR 45], you could search for People v. Geiger or just Geiger. Searching for Geiger might be more helpful since it would find references to the case that do not include the full citation.

  • Contact Us
  • Log In
  • My Account

  • Home
  • Firm Overview
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Practice Areas
  • Verdicts & Settlements
  • News & media
  • Blog
  • Contact

Back to  Previous Page
Back to top

Return to CALJIC Part 14-17 – Contents

F 14.41a

Petty Theft With Prior Conviction–Prior Admitted:

Prejudicial Reference To Prior

(PC 666)

*Modify Title of CJ 14.41 as follows [deleted language is between << >>]:

PETTY THEFT <<WITH PRIOR CONVICTION — PRIOR ADMITTED>>

Points & Authorities

It is established that the defendant has the right to admit a prior conviction and thereby preclude the jury from learning about this fact during the trial of a petty theft charge. (See People v. Bouzas (91) 53 C3d 467, 480 [279 CR 847].) However, it would obviously defeat the purpose of such a stipulation and prejudice the defendant to inform the jury in the instructions that the defendant has admitted a prior conviction. However, this is exactly what CJ 14.41 does if it is submitted to the jury with the title left intact. The title provides as follows: “Petty Theft With Prior Conviction–Prior Admitted.”

Exposure of the jury to this title is in effect exposure to a fact not in evidence. “Jury exposure to facts not in evidence deprives a defendant of the rights to confrontation, cross-examination and assistance of counsel embodied in the 6th Amendment. [Citations.]” (Lawson v. Borg (9th Cir. 1995) 60 F3d 608, 612; see also, U.S. v. Vasquez (9th Cir. 1979) 597 F2d 192, 193-94 [inadvertent jury exposure to a file showing defendant had suffered prior conviction warranted reversal]; see also generally Crawford v. Washington (2004) 541 US 36 [158 LEd2d 177; 124 SCt 1354] [recognizing importance of 6th Amendment right to confrontation].) Moreover, jury exposure to other crimes evidence has a “substantial prejudicial effect” upon the jury. (People v. Ewoldt (94) 7 C4th 380, 404 [27 CR2d 646].) Moreover, although the prejudicial effect is heightened when the other crime is similar (People v. Johnson (91) 233 CA3d 425, 459 [284 CR 579]), the presentation of an unspecified prior felony conviction to the jury invites prejudicial speculation. (See People v. Rollo (77) 20 C3d 109, 115-20 [141 CR 177]; see also People v. Stewart (2004) 33 C4th 425, 479 [not unreasonable for counsel to opt for specification of several specific priors in lieu of having unspecified prior]; People v. Barrick (82) 33 C3d 115, 126-28 [187 CR 716]; People v. Jimenez (9th Cir. 2000) 214 F3d 1095, 1099 [reference to prior as “felony involving firearm” was improper].)

Accordingly, the title to CJ 14.41 should either be modified as set forth above or deleted entirely from the instructions given to the jury. (See PG V(D)(2); see Brief Bank # B-751 for additional briefing.)

NOTES

This instruction illustrates a problem which may result from leaving the titles on the written instructions submitted to the jury. (See FORECITE PG V(D)(2).)


F 14.41b

Petty Theft With Prior — Prior Admitted:

Intent To Deprive Of Main Or Major Value

*Modify CJ 14.41 as follows [added language is capitalized]:

Every person who steals, takes, carries, leads or drives away the personal property of another with the specific intent to [permanently deprive the owner of [his] [her] property] [DEPRIVE THE OWNER OF THE [MAIN] [MAJOR] VALUE OF [HIS] [HER] PROPERTY] is guilty of the crime of petty theft.

Points and Authorities

See FORECITE F 9.40p.

  • Register as New User
  • Contact Us
© James Publishing, Inc. (866) 72-JAMES