Logo
Searching Tips

When searching Forecite California, there are shortcuts you can take to find the information you are looking for:

1. By Code Section:

Forecite uses standard abbreviations for different types of codes. Those abbreviations can be found below:

Codes:
CCR California Code of Regulations
Corp C Corporations Code
EC Evidence Code
FG Fish and Game Code
GC Government Code
HN Harbors & Navigation Code
HS Health & Safety Code
PC Penal Code
RT Revenue & Tax Code
VC Vehicle Code
WI Welfare & Institutions Code

Using these codes to search is very simple. For example, if you wanted to search for Penal Code section 20, you would type PC 20 into the search box.

2. By CALJIC Number:

Since Forecite is indexed to CALJIC, searching for CALJIC numbers is easy. For example, to search for CALJIC 3.16, you would type 3.16 into the search box.

3. By Case Name or Citation:

To find a case or citation, simply enter all or part of the case’s citation. Since many cases are known only by one name involved, it is often helpful to not search for the entire citation. For example, if you were searching for references to People v. Geiger (84) 35 C3d 510, 526 [199 CR 45], you could search for People v. Geiger or just Geiger. Searching for Geiger might be more helpful since it would find references to the case that do not include the full citation.

  • Contact Us
  • Log In
  • My Account

  • Home
  • Firm Overview
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Practice Areas
  • Verdicts & Settlements
  • News & media
  • Blog
  • Contact

Back to  Previous Page
Back to top

SERIES 800 ASSAULTIVE AND BATTERY CRIMES

F 810 NOTES

TABLE OF CONTENTS
F 810 Note 1 Torture: CALCRIM Cross-References And Research Notes
F 810 Note 2 Torture: Battery And Mayhem Lesser Included Offenses (PC 206)
F 810 Note 3 Second Degree Torture Murder Per PC 206 Included In Torture Murder (PC 206)
F 810 Note 4 Torture: Requirement Of Prolonged Pain (PC 206)
F 810 Note 5 Unconstitutional Vagueness Of The Terms “Cruel,” “Sadistic Purpose,” “Torture” And “Extortion” (PC 206)
F 810 Note 6 Torture: Evidence Required
F 810 Note 7 Torture: PC 206 Not Vague Or Overbroad
F 810 Note 8 Torture: Personal Infliction Of GBI Not Required (PC 206 / PC 12022.7)

Return to Series 800 Table of Contents.


F 810 Note 1 Torture: CALCRIM Cross-References And Research Notes

CALCRIM Cross References:

CALCRIM 520 [First Degree Torture Murder]
CALCRIM 733 [Special Circumstances: Murder With Torture]

Research Notes:

See CLARAWEB Forum, Assaultive And Battery Crimes—Series 800-900.


F 810 Note 2 Torture: Battery And Mayhem Lesser Included Offenses (PC 206)

Assaultive Crimes (PC 245, PC 273a, PC 273d, PC 273.5) and battery (PC 242, PC 243 et seq.) should be lesser included offenses of torture (PC 206). The infliction of pain required for torture necessarily includes the commission of an act resulting in an unlawful touching of the victim.

CALJIC NOTE: See FORECITE F 9.90 n1.


F 810 Note 3 Second Degree Torture Murder Per PC 206 Included In Torture Murder (PC 206)

See FORECITE F 8.24 n4.

RESEARCH NOTE: For additional information on hate crimes, see Should Hate Be Punishable (The Recorder, December 28, 1992) and For ACLU, Hate Crimes Are a Divisive Issue (The Recorder, December 28, 1992).

CALJIC NOTE: See FORECITE F 9.90 n2.


F 810 Note 4 Torture: Requirement Of Prolonged Pain (PC 206)

The Bench Notes to CC 810 cites cases for the proposition that prolonged pain is not required by PC 206. However, without such a requirement, torture may be found in any case where extreme pain was inflicted, even though the pain was only momentary or fleeting. (E.g., a severe blow or bullet to the head.) To allow a finding of torture in such a case would be inconsistent with the intent of the statute and would produce irrational results in violation of substantive due process. (See generally, Gray v. Whitmore (1971) 17 CA3d 1, 21; Blaylock v. Schwinden (9th Cir. 1988) 862 F2d 1352, 1354.) Hence, CJ 9.90 should be modified to require an intent to inflict “extreme and prolonged” pain. (See People v. Steger (1976) 16 C3d 539, 548; see also People v. Healy (1993) 14 CA4th 1137, 1140-42 [Steger definition of torture utilized for purposes of evaluating the sufficiency of evidence to support a PC 206 torture conviction].)

RESEARCH NOTE: For additional information on hate crimes, see Should Hate Be Punishable (The Recorder, December 28, 1992) and For ACLU, Hate Crimes Are a Divisive Issue (The Recorder, December 28, 1992).

CALJIC NOTE: See FORECITE F 9.90 n4.


F 810 Note 5 Unconstitutional Vagueness Of The Terms “Cruel,” “Sadistic Purpose,” “Torture” And “Extortion” (PC 206)

As used in PC 206, the above terms may be unconstitutionally vague. Although the California Courts of Appeal have upheld the constitutionality of the statute. (See People v. Barrera (1993) 14 CA4th 1555, 1564-70; People v. Healy (1993) 14 CA4th 1137; see also People v. Aguilar (1997) 58 CA4th 1196 [PC 206 is not unconstitutionally vague or overbroad]), the constitutionality of the statute has not been resolved by the California Supreme Court or by the federal courts. (But see People v. Raley (1992) 2 C4th 870, 897-902 as to “sadistic purpose.”) [See Brief Bank # B-572 for briefing on these issues.]

RESEARCH NOTE: For additional information on hate crimes, see Should Hate Be Punishable (The Recorder, December 28, 1992) and For ACLU, Hate Crimes Are a Divisive Issue (The Recorder, December 28, 1992).

CALJIC NOTE: See FORECITE F 9.90 n5.


F 810 Note 6 Torture: Evidence Required

[See Brief Bank # B-725 for briefing discussing the legislative history of PC 206 and the nature of the evidence required to support the crime of torture.]

CALJIC NOTE: See FORECITE F 9.90 n6.


F 810 Note 7 Torture: PC 206 Not Vague Or Overbroad

In People v. Aguilar (1997) 58 CA4th 1196 the court held that PC 206 is not unconstitutionally vague or overbroad and made a number of rulings regarding the law of torture under PC 206.

CALJIC NOTE: See FORECITE F 9.90 n7.


F 810 Note 8 Torture: Personal Infliction Of GBI Not Required (PC 206 / PC 12022.7)

(See People v. Lewis (2004) 120 CA4th 882, 889 [unlike PC 12022.7, PC 206 does not require personal infliction of torture].)

CALJIC NOTE: See FORECITE F 9.90 n8.

  • Register as New User
  • Contact Us
© James Publishing, Inc. (866) 72-JAMES